Church Life Today
Hosted by Dr. Leonard DeLorenzo, of the McGrath Institute for Church Life at the University of Notre Dame (http://mcgrath.nd.edu), Church Life Today features conversations with pastoral leaders and scholars from around the country and covers issues that matter most to Church life today. Church Life Today is an OSV Podcasts partner.
Church Life Today
Time Exposures: Catholic Photography and the Evolution of Modern China, with Joseph Ho and Anthony Clark
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Somewhere in your house there is a box of photographs no one has looked at in years. You know the faces in the older ones only because someone once told you who they were. The moment will not come again; the people in it have mostly gone. And yet you keep the box, because you know that you came from those faces, and that without them you would not be who you are.
“Photographs deal with things that are always vanishing.”
Henri Cartier-Bresson, quoted by Anthony Clark in this episode
That is true, as far as it goes. But a photograph does something else, too. It holds a moment still long enough for the living to find their roots in it.
For a hundred years, Catholic missionaries in China carried cameras. They outnumbered the diplomats and the journalists, and so their archives in Rome, Paris, Brussels, Boston, and Spokane hold the largest surviving visual record of China before the Cultural Revolution. In those images are baptisms and processions, orphanages and seminaries, sisters at work and bishops at prayer, churches rising in villages and churches in ruins. Most of the images have never been published. Many of the people in them cannot be named. But the Church they show is not a Church that vanished. It is the Church that endured, and that is still there, and the Catholics of China today are its heirs.
To look closely at these photographs, then, is not an exercise in nostalgia. It is a way of seeing what persists: the devotion that outlasted persecution, the faces behind the names in the martyrologies, and the moment when Chinese Catholics themselves took hold of the camera and began to show the world their own Church. My guests have spent years in the archives learning how to see this way, and in this conversation they teach us to see it too.
They are the authors of Time Exposures: Catholic Photography and the Evolution of Modern China. Joseph Ho is a historian of modern China and visual culture at the University of Michigan. Anthony Clark, who joined me last year to talk about Matteo Ricci, is professor of Chinese history and holder of the Edward B. Lindaman Endowed Chair at Whitworth University.
FOLLOW-UP RESOURCES
The book and the authors
Time Exposures: Catholic Photography and the Evolution of Modern China — Joseph W. Ho and Anthony E. Clark (Hong Kong University Press, 2026)
Developing Mission: Photography, Filmmaking, and American Missionaries in Modern China — Joseph W. Ho (Cornell University Press, 2022)
Anthony E. Clark: publications — including China’s Saints and China Gothic
Société des Auxiliaires des Missions (SAM) China Photograph Collection — Whitworth University Library; many of the book’s images, including the 1937 Manila voyage, are digitized here
Previous Church Life Today episodes
The Evangelizing Brilliance and Errors of Matteo Ricci, with Anthony Clark — April 21, 2025
Religion in China, with Ian Johnson — November 1, 2019
From Church Life Journal
In the Footsteps of Dialogue: China and the Legacy of Matteo Ricci — Anthony Clark, February 17, 2026
China’s Divided Church Under Pope Francis — Paul P. Mariani, September 2, 2025
China’s Religious Awakening After Mao — Ian Johnson, June 11, 2020
The Clash Between the Jesuits and Traditional Chinese Square-Earth Cosmology — James Hannam, March 11, 2022
Church Life Today is a partnership between the McGrath Institute for Church Life at the University of Notre Dame and OSV Podcasts from Our Sunday Visitor. Discover more ways to live, learn, and love your Catholic faith at osvpodcasts.com. Sharing stories, starting conversations.
From the McGrath Institute for Church Life and OSV Podcast, this is Church Life Today. I'm Leonard DiLorenzo. Somewhere in your house there is a box of photographs no one has looked at in years. You know the faces in the older ones only because someone once told you who they were. The moment will not come again. The people in it have mostly gone. And yet you keep the box because you know that you came from those faces and that without them you would not be who you are. Photographs deal with things that are always vanishing. That is true as far as it goes. But a photograph does something else too. It holds a moment still long enough for the living to find their roots in it. For a hundred years, Catholic missionaries in China carried cameras. They outnumbered the diplomats and the journalists, and so their archives in Rome, Paris, Brussels, Boston, and Spokane hold the largest surviving visual record of China before the Cultural Revolution. In those images are baptisms and processions, orphanages and seminaries, sisters at work and bishops at prayer, churches rising in villages and churches in ruins. Most of the images have never been published. Many of the people in them cannot be named. But the church they show is not a church that vanished. It is the church that endured and that is still there. And the Catholics of China today are its heirs. To look closely at these photographs, then is not an exercise in nostalgia. It is a way of seeing what persists. The devotion that outlasted persecution, the faces behind the names in the martyrologies, and the moment when Chinese Catholics themselves took hold of the camera and began to show the world their own church. My guests have spent years in the archives learning how to see this way, And in this conversation, they teach us to see it too. They are the authors of Time Exposures, Catholic Photography and the Evolution of Modern China. Joseph Ho is an historian of modern China and visual culture at the University of Michigan. Anthony Clark, who joined me last year to talk about Matteo Ricci, is professor of Chinese history and holder of the Edward B. Lindemann Endowed Chair at Whitworth University. Joseph, welcome to Church Life Today. Thanks for having me. And Tony, welcome back to the show. It's good to see you again. It's good to be back. Thank you. Joseph, Tony, your work that we're talking about today is, I've got to say, equally stunning in its visual quality and in the meticulousness of the act of historical retrieval and interpretation that it brings forth. But before we get to the work itself, I wanted to spend, if you wouldn't mind, a couple minutes on maybe some preliminaries. And the first preliminary before we enter into the book is actually to start at the title of the book, which is Time Exposures. It ends up being, after having read through this, the perfect title for the book. But for those of us who might not be as familiar with this term and especially how it will relate to your work, I wonder if you might offer us an explanation of time exposures.
SPEAKER_01Sure. So it's a bit of play on words, time exposures being the kind of long exposure that one uses in photography to expose a scene for a long period of time. And it's a play on words in the sense that it's also about the layers of history and the change over time that takes place in the narratives and the images and the communities that we look at. So we chose that title as a way of bringing together the visual experiences and qualities of our work, as well as the many evolutions that China and Catholicism and China has gone through in the years that we covered.
SPEAKER_02Excellent. And I also think that, um, at least from my point of view, let me also sort of preface all my remarks with how much of an honor it was to write this book with Joseph, who's the true expert in the history and dynamics of photography. But uh I couldn't help when I was thinking about this title that Joseph actually selected. It's a beautiful title, this quote by Ansel Adams that photography is usually looked at, seldom looked into. And there's something about um what we're trying to do to, in a sense, expose people to a time that has vanished. And um, you know, I love the the title of this podcast, Church Life Today. But church life today really uh doesn't exist without church life in the past. So this book captures, it exposes us really to the things that have happened uh among missionaries and Christians in China in a previous era.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's so helpful. I wanted to ask then, just sort of moving past the title and keeping that in mind, actually to the title of the first chapter, which is Photographic Visions. And you write in that first chapter that photographic vision includes the views of those behind the camera, in front of the camera, and those who view photographs long after they were printed, preserved, and even digitized. So for those of us hearing that for the first time, we can already uh grasp a bit of the sense of the time exposures that you're talking about there. My question is on the basis of that, what is distinctive about the photographic photographic visions in this book? What are the photographic visions that we're treated to here?
SPEAKER_01So I would say that the distinctiveness comes from the kinds of in-betweenness, the different worlds that these makers and subjects and audiences of these images are living in, the worlds of modern China, the uh Catholic Church in China, the national and the local at the same time, or in between these worlds. And the ways that we um approach these images and these experiences take into account the idea and the existence that these images are not just finished products, they're not just surfaces, but they are a combination or layers of various imaginations, experiences, technologies, and ways of seeing that exist between all of these worlds.
SPEAKER_02And I think too of this um this fact that history is so contended. And uh and if you think about uh, for example, the question of abandoned infants in China, you know, there are lots of historians who disagree with what the percentage was of female uh babies that were abandoned. The most common statistic or the most common percentage is about 25%. Well, um all the photographs that we talk about are essentially curated photographs. So I'm thinking of uh I'm thinking of the image, I think it's in the first chapter, uh one 115, and it's of some sisters collecting abandoned infants. Well, in this case, the photograph, the photographs is helping us to resolve debates that exist in the historical fields. And and I really, I really love two things that are happening. One is, and I love how Joseph frames looking at these images, but as curated images, I mean, we know that all historians curate what we write about. But as curated images, we know that the the photographer is framing it to emphasize a certain thing. In this case, the collection of abandoned babies. And you can see the person who's collecting the babies on a pole with two baskets. And I just really uh appreciate uh what what what you see in the images is curated, but it's also curated from a Catholic point of view. And that gives that that allows us to access a kind of denominational uh or creedal perspective and how we think about the the images or how we think about what the readers or viewers will will see.
SPEAKER_03And that's I mean, I I was struck, I had to come back to the uh image that's there on the cover of the work that Joseph designed the cover uh as I read on the back. And this um this photograph on the cover, which has a Chinese seminarian adjusting a roly chord camera behind two Chinese bishops, right? So here in this framing, you have also captured, uh he didn't seem to know that he was being captured there, this seminarian who's uh preparing his technological equipment of the camera for another scene. I wonder when did you first, maybe each of you or or together, when did you first see Chinese Catholics as photographers rather than just subjects with this photography?
SPEAKER_01I would say it's certainly in images like the one on the cover, um, which I also love because it combines all the elements of the Catholic Church's presence in modern China. We have um, you know, a Boy Scout in the background, along with the seminarian. We have people wearing Western clothing and traditional clothing. We have a great picture of um the father of modern China, Sung at Sen, right in the middle. And then also these um faces of kids peeking out through the window, staring back at the photographer making this formal image, and they're kind of inadvertently imaged in this picture. But I would say it's finding these materials that Tony has collected over many years, also encountering them in archives of traces of um Catholic individuals talking about photography, showing up in photographs, writing about the ways in which they think about cameras and devices and circulating images, and realizing that there's an entire visual culture out there that's essentially hidden in plain sight in archives and in some of these experiences.
SPEAKER_02Um I should say that it was it was Joseph who designed this very fantastic cover. And uh also what's great, I until this moment I never noticed the children looking through the the window in the door behind the two bishops. I didn't notice that until you just said it, yeah. Right. This is this is the the the adeptness that Joseph has at viewing photographs. Um I can't I can't help but think of Bresson, Henri Cartier Bresson's sort of assertion that photographs deal with things that are always vanishing. And here we have here we have this example of something that many people might just walk by, children, you know, peering out through the door windows. Um it's obviously a framed photograph on the cover. I mean, it's clearly part of a uh, you know, they're commemorating the opening of a church. But um, you know, most of us walk by uh beautiful or important, significant things, and we don't think about it. And in this instance, the the camera has has, as Bresson says, has captured what is usually a vanishing moment. And um also from from my point of view, one of the things I really enjoy about this particular image is that it it places uh these photographs in a certain time, the era when Sun Yat-sen was emerging as one of the dominant thinkers in what we think of as modern China, um, as Joseph says, the father of China, the father of modern China, the Guofu, as they say. But also you see two Chinese bishops, and this is a time when when Chinese uh uh priests were being consecrated bishops for the first time. So we're seeing newly consecrated bishops who are starting a whole new era in the Catholic community in in China.
SPEAKER_03Hmm. We're gonna talk about specific photographs, I hope, uh in the minutes to come. But I asked I actually was uh struck right at the beginning of the book that you don't start necessarily with a photograph. You actually start with a letter, a letter about photographs, which is this letter from a Jesuit missionary, I think written in April of the year 1900, in which he is describing five photographs that he has mailed home. What did that letter teach you about how to read every photograph that then follows in this work?
SPEAKER_02Right. So in that instance, that particular Jesuit will end up being martyred in 1900. Uh, and he is today a canonized saint within the Catholic Church. When when one accesses the letters by those Jesuits who lived in China, uh, they're held in the archive in Volve. And that's a lovely thing about this particular book, is that there is an international sweep of photographs that were consulted from all over the world, um, from so many countries. And in that particular letter, uh you see that this Jesuit is missing home and he's connecting with his family, but he's also really trying to let his family members and his friends know what is life like in China. And so often, uh, you know, well, we're so grateful that that archives exist. And in this digital age, I mean, who knows how what how we're going to preserve the profundity of images that are captured on cell phones, right? But in this instance, you can go through the letter and then you find these photographs and you you have a connection. It's it's more metadata than you usually find on the back of the picture. The picture is usually who it is, the date, and and maybe that's it. But in this case, we have an entire letter about these photographs. And then from my point of view, it's also quite um summoning to hold the letter of someone you you know will die, a really horrible death, in just a few years after he wrote that letter and sent those photographs overseas. And then I guess lastly, I'll say that in the 1960s, during the Cultural Revolution, 67, 68, a tremendous number of photographs were destroyed. Um and so it's it's also telling that a lot of these images that you find of China are found outside of China.
SPEAKER_01I would also add to Tony's point here that it's a great reminder that all these images and these histories have lives and afterlives. So the images may be curated or exist in tension or conjunction with experiences and imaginations in the historical moment, and then they go places, they move through space and time. And in doing so, they accrue meanings, they become part of other commemorations or invisibilities or visibilities, silences, and then recovery processes. And then I think the joy of this book is to live through and think about all of those different pieces of the lives and the afterlives in relation to this type of image making.
SPEAKER_03This is, as we mentioned just a moment ago, a Jesuit missionary who you begin with in his letter. And I it makes me wonder about why missionaries are so important to the historical photographic record of China, especially before the onset of the Cultural Revolution. Can you speak to that a little bit?
SPEAKER_02One thing that strikes me about this particular project that Joseph and I worked on was discovering that not only are these missionaries sending photographs home to let their families know about their lives in China, I mean they're adjusting to eating with sticks. This is something they write about quite frequently. How can I eat with with chopsticks? They're French, most of them. But um, but in in addition to this, I I think that um that um I think that what one what one sees is that these photographs were not just used to preserve memories, but they were used to solicit funds. And uh they were often shown in slideshows back in Europe and in the United States to to show the success of the missionaries. And then after that, there was almost uh, well now, there was always uh a plea for financial assistance. And so, you know, you see that these the well it's not it's not exactly cheap to carry around these cameras and and to pay for or to get the chemicals needed to uh to to process the the film. So um you see them photographing and and publishing images in in a in a kind of fundraising project. And then the funds that they gather, they spent on buying new cameras and sometimes uh films, uh cameras, so that they could preserve moving images. So a lot of it is not just memory, but a lot of it is uh soliciting support.
SPEAKER_01I would also add to that perspective, um, certainly this connection between China and the rest of the world, that in the in the context of this connection, missionaries are mediators. So they are mediators for churches within China, uh, congregations outside of China, and then they also, in the process of mediation, become intentional or accidental documentarians or ethnographers or photojournalists, depending on whether China is in peace or China is at war, mediating between warlords and communists and nationalists and foreign powers. They're always in between. And they're also collaborators and connected to Chinese Catholics who are themselves mediators, who are themselves also image makers. So there's all of these different elements ranging from fundraising to photojournalism in the process of mediation that connects the missionary as well as the Chinese Catholic groups.
SPEAKER_03It makes me wonder if there's a distinction between what's remained and been studied from uh Protestant missionaries on the one hand and Catholic missionaries on the other. Would either of you be able to speak to that? Is there something there?
SPEAKER_01Happy to. So my uh research has focused both on Catholic groups and Protestant groups. And one thing you see with uh both of these groups is that they have common themes, of course, of covering images of religious activities, of education, of different political and social dynamics in China. But in the Protestant sense, there is a different type of network that's often connected to families, to um, of course, direct descendants of children of Protestant missionaries and sometimes grandchildren, multiple generations for whom these images are family photos as well as documents of China and missions. Of course, there is also a different set of networks in terms of fundraising and support, as well as the development of an entirely um coexistent Chinese Protestantism that is in the same place and time as Chinese Catholics also developing their groups. Sometimes there is ecumenical contact, and sometimes there is conflict between these groups in very uh uh serious ways. So I would say that there is a an entire constellation of photography that is existing in China between Catholics and Protestants, and to explore all of these in their richness is such a joy.
SPEAKER_02Well, one of the things that strikes me, and I'm so glad that Joseph answered that question first, because one of the things that strikes me is where are these photographs held in their afterlives? And if you think about the Catholic context, you have a lot of missionaries who are sending their photographs back to institutional archives. So they're in the archives of orders, they're in Rome at the Franciscan Archive and the Jesuit archive and the Lazarus archive and maybe the Benedictine archive. But contrarily, in the Protestant context, um, as Joseph has discovered, so many of these photographs are found in the homes of the grandchildren or the children of missionaries. And you find them, you know, in the back of the house in a box, it's which is a very different kind of way to to to to think about these images. And also one of the things I think we point out in this book is that when you look at Catholic photographs, sometimes they look an awful lot like holy cards. You know, they have this pious devotional life that informs how they frame images, such as you know, this tendency in Catholic photography to photograph people holding or staring at a crucifix, you know, and maybe holding a rosary or wearing a scapular. And in the in the Protestant context, and maybe Joseph can say more about this, you see families, you see hospital things, you see. People gathering for Christmas gatherings or funerals. Very different modes of framing the images.
SPEAKER_01And certainly different modes of symbolism, holding a Bible or being in a space with more Protestant scriptural writings on the walls. And those separations, those differences are really unique to how people present themselves in images and also where these images ultimately go, as Tony has so beautifully said here.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's so fantastic to think about. I mean, we're, of course, we have this sort of now cliched uh saying that, you know, whether life imitates art or art imitates life, but in this case, it's the framing of life that is being uh sort of directed or influenced by the sacred art that has entered into the imagination. Where is the sacred um in the mundane, or is it is it there in a in a separate type of space that then is represented in the framing of the image itself? It's quite interesting. I wonder if you could guide us then through maybe a couple of different images that we can move a little bit closer to. And I asked you if you could help direct me towards some of the ones that might be especially interesting to talk about. So if I could, if I could move us to one of those now, which Joseph, you had pointed out what is figure four.10, which for those who haven't seen the book, this is the bombed auditorium in Nanjing in 1937. It's the interior image of that. There's a corresponding exterior image in figure 4.11, but we'll look at the interior photograph here. Could you, maybe Joseph, I suppose maybe you could start here. Could you uh help to explain to us or describe to us what we see in this photograph? And of course, folks who are listening don't have the benefit yet, um, as they're listening, of seeing this. So we'll have to sort of uh through our words visually describe what we're seeing.
SPEAKER_01Great. So this is a photograph that's attributed to a uh Catholic missionary named Raymond Jaeger. And uh it's an image of an auditorium in the then capital of China, the city of Nanjing, in the early stages of the Japanese invasion of China, which started in the summer of 1937. And this image uh is so striking because it's it's taken from the inside of this auditorium. There's a giant shell or bomb hole blasted through the back of this auditorium, which, you know, in peacetime would have been used to train public servants and scientific professionals. It's part of the National Health Administration of the Republic of China. And this hole blasted through this auditorium is a symbol of the woundedness or the trauma that China as a modern nation is enduring at this point in time under Japanese military invasion in the first stages of this war. And in my research, uh thinking about modern China and this period in Chinese history, there's always this kind of bittersweet possibility or moment in the 1930s where China is on the rise, it is pushing off kind of foreign uh pressures, it is developing as a modern nation, and all of this kind of comes to a halt uh or is violently disrupted the moment the Japanese invade China in 1937. And this photograph has the symbols of the modern Republic of China. It's got the national flag is there, Sun Yat-sen's portrait is on uh the podium, on this, you know, emptied out, bombed-out auditorium. And there's this representation here of a uh what another scholar of Chinese photography calls wound culture, of China as a modern nation having suffered immense different types of trauma uh in different immense ways. And this image symbolizes that. And yet all of this is also documented by a Catholic missionary embedded in China, who is also transmitting this image to others as a representation of Catholic mediation and also of China's suffering during this tremendously chaotic period in its modern history.
SPEAKER_03What would you say that the Catholic record of 1937 changes about how the Nanjing story is told or received?
SPEAKER_01It's a great question. Traditionally, and I would say for much of conventional historical scholarship, even now, many images and accounts of the Japanese occupation of Nanjing, what becomes the Nanjing massacre or the rape of Nanjing, many of those accounts are traced to Protestant missionaries who are active in that city, running hospitals, uh setting up refugee camps, um, making images and films too. But what's kind of missing is that Catholic groups were equally active at this time in Nanjing, providing shelter for refugees, providing medical care, documenting violence, uh, transmitting accounts of this horrific moment in Nanjing's history and China's history to outside audiences, all under the rubric of Christian internationalism, this idea that religion and Christianity transcends boundaries and political borders. And we as Catholics can do something to help these war-stricken area and people in this area, in conjunction with other groups who are Protestant, also Buddhist charities are active in this time. And that part of the history with the Catholic involvement has often been erased or invisible in conventional scholarship that focuses very strongly on Protestant humanitarian work in Nanjing during this time.
SPEAKER_02I can't help but think of Raymond Deeger at that moment. He's traveling around China and Joseph discovered really, he saw that there was this packet of photographs about Nanjing during this during this Japanese invasion. And some of them are quite gruesome. And um, but I can't help but but just sort of imagine Raymond Dieger with his camera, who normally took photographs, you know, normally took group photographs at events, traveling around Nanjing and specifically finding these places that were wounded, as Joseph uh frames it, and and photographing them and saving them in a packet that has never been looked at before, as far as I know, until they end up uh they end up in the pages of this book.
SPEAKER_01I would add there that some of the images um I can tell have um push pin holes in the the margins, in that they were displayed somewhere, but the images that Tony is mentioning here, with these more gruesome uh images of victims uh and bodies were not pinned up. They were not displayed. They might have been privately shared. And I feel a kind of sense of Raymond Dieeger trying to get the word out about violence, but also preserving the dignity of the victims of some of this violence in a balanced way to say, here are images of trauma. We need to stop this war, and yet here are some images of atrocities and violence that we will try to keep a little bit in the background to preserve dignity in a way that's um you know physical and visible at the same time.
SPEAKER_03I'm so glad you commented on that. I was gonna ask a question about it, so I'm glad that you brought this up. But I was also noticing this is just my own observation, and I'm sure you've seen this as well. When you flip from 4.10, which is the interior photograph, to 4.11, which is from the the outside, looking at the, you know, back upon the same scene, what is in light or what is the source of light and what is darkness flips. So when you're inside, it's only dark, except for the whole of the violence that was perpetrated. The the wound, in other words, the light comes in there. When you're on the outside and it's in the light of day, the source of light is, of course, the sun, the ambient sun all around. And that same wound is now the point of darkness, which is just so interesting to me. I I didn't I didn't have a full reflection on it, but I just kept flipping back and forth to notice that difference. If we could then maybe move to a to a second photo that you pointed out to me, which this one I spent uh after you you uh directed my attention to it so much time learning about it and and learning to see it a little bit better. But um, I'm wondering if you could help us with this one as well. This is 5.11. And this one is bishop, is it Zhu at uh in front of the display that would be sent to Manila to the 33rd Eucharistic Congress in Manila also in 1937, correct? That's right. Yeah. Help us to know this one a little bit.
SPEAKER_01I love this image. I love it because it has the connections to modern technology, a Chinese Catholic church that is moving also beyond China and connections to the world. Uh, for readers and listeners of uh this podcast, it's an image of uh Bishop Drew standing next to a um uh exhibit that's framed, uh it's a kind of um display that looks like a Chinese gate. And in the gate itself, there is this uh set of photographs of the Hyman Vicariate displaying different groups, activities, kind of arrayed around the um the frame of the gate, as well as a map of the Hyman Vicariate as well. And what's lovely about this is that this display was built in China, moved to Manila for this uh exhibit, and itself is a technological um achievement because you have all of these different light bulbs that you can't quite see in the picture, but they're described in other documentation. Light bulbs connected to the map that are also linked to individual photos, and visitors to the exhibit could press buttons on the panel of the display and light up uh electrical connections to show photos associated with different locations in this area in China, in this Catholic um uh environment. And it's simultaneously this technological, religious, communal, and material artifact that moves through space and time and is connected to Chinese indigenous Catholic experience.
SPEAKER_03And it's like a prototype of a diocesan website, is it not?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03Remarkable. Well, before it's time. What do you see here, Tony? What did anything draw your attention here?
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, from from my point of view, what what what I latch on to when I look at this image is sort of thinking about the history of Bishop Zhu. I mean, he's consecrated in in 1926. He's one of the first of the uh he's one, he's in the first group of a group of bishops who were consecrated in Rome by the Pope in 1926. And here he is fulfilling his mission. You know, what the Pope wanted him to do was to go out and promote the work in China. And he does so with this sort of technological panache that um it was must have been incredibly just visually astonishing to those looking at him. And he was a Jesuit. So he had, so you know, if you think about the large sweep of the Jesuit network, Bishop Ju's photographs were saved, preserved, and republished all over the world. So uh he just represents kind of the, you know, among those first six bishops, Chinese bishops who were consecrated in 1926. Bishop Ju was the rock star of all of them. And uh this this image shows that that kind of that phenomenon that he was promoting. And also interesting is how almost chinoiserie-esque is this display that he's in front of. Uh they're definitely playing to, you know, trying to broadcast something that looks as Chinese as possible.
SPEAKER_03You know, you mentioned I was going to ask you if you could share with us a little bit about Bishop Zhu and you've given us an introduction there, and one of the things you mentioned that is that he was consecrated a bishop in 1926. Actually looked up the date. You know what the date was? Today, October 28th.
SPEAKER_02Oh my god, that's right, October 28th.
SPEAKER_03This is the day that we're recording, of course, not the day that people will be listening to this, but we're on the centenary of his consecration.
SPEAKER_02The exact 100-year anniversary is right now of the consecration by Pius XI in the Vatican. That's amazing.
SPEAKER_03Thanks for pointing out. That itself is a time exposure. No, I I had to check it about four different times to make sure that I wasn't just trying to will something into existence. That's awesome. It is, it is, it is. Well, this, you know, this of course is just a brief um introduction to the incredible treasury of photographs that you've brought forward in this book and all of the, as I said at the beginning, meticulous and wonderful work of retrieval and interpretation that goes alongside it. For people who have not yet seen this, and we'll include links in our show notes so people can find this work and hopefully follow up by seeing it themselves. I wonder if you might bring us towards a close by answering this question. It's a difficult question, I suppose, a simple but a difficult one. But from your perspective, what would you hope that a Catholic in the pews might see when they look at these pictures?
SPEAKER_02Um there's an interesting quote by Emile Zola who said that you you cannot claim to have seen something until you photographed it. I don't know that I agree with that entirely, but but what Zola is trying to say is that uh we might know that things have happened, but or we might have seen things, but we really haven't captured them. And I think that this book forces us to stop and recognize that we're truly seeing what what was what what the church looked like, or truly seeing what China looked like in a way that we wouldn't see were it not captured in a photograph. So, from my point of view, um the modern Catholic, well, I I should back up. When I ask Chinese Catholics, what do you want the rest of the world to know? Almost in almost uh unanimously they'll respond, I want I want the rest of the world to know that we're here. That's a pretty simple request, isn't it? That that China has a Christian community, and that the rest of the Christian world can and should recognize that their brothers and sisters are are in China as well. So I think that that that desire of Chinese Catholics is fulfilled in this book because we not only show them that the Catholicism exists in China or that Christianity exists in China, but that it has for a long time and it's been recorded. So Zola gets his way. We talk about photographs, and people can truly see the church at that time.
SPEAKER_01And adding to what Tony has wonderfully shared here, I would love for readers to be able to understand the richness and the trajectories of Chinese Catholicism and the global church as visualized here in this book, in these experiences, in these histories, tying it back to a lovely thought from the French philosopher and semiotician Roland Barth, who wrote an excellent book called Camera Lucida, Reflections on Photography. And he references the fact that every single photograph is a has-been, an existence or an emanation of a past reality, which also means that if every single photo is a has-been, there are also numerous will-be's, existences of the future, imaginations of the future. And I would love to have people understand and think about the will-bees, the trajectories that will go on in these connections between the Chinese church, the global church, and these images and experiences that transcend time.
SPEAKER_03Time exposures indeed. Wonderful. Friends, the book that we have been discussing together, or the basis of our conversation, is Time Exposures: Catholic Photography and the Evolution of Modern China. It is written by Joseph Ho and Anthony Clark, my guest today. It's out now from Hong Kong University Press. We will link to it in the show notes. Joseph and Tony, thank you so very much for spending this time with us today.
SPEAKER_02Thank you.
SPEAKER_03Thank you. And thanks as always to all of you for joining us on Church Life today.
SPEAKER_00This has been a production of OSV Podcasts. To learn more, visit OSVPodcasts.com.