Church Life Today

Time Exposures: Catholic Photography and the Evolution of Modern China, with Joseph Ho and Anthony Clark

• OSV Podcasts

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 39:50

Somewhere in your house there is a box of photographs no one has looked at in years. You know the faces in the older ones only because someone once told you who they were. The moment will not come again; the people in it have mostly gone. And yet you keep the box, because you know that you came from those faces, and that without them you would not be who you are.

“Photographs deal with things that are always vanishing.”

Henri Cartier-Bresson, quoted by Anthony Clark in this episode

That is true, as far as it goes. But a photograph does something else, too. It holds a moment still long enough for the living to find their roots in it.

For a hundred years, Catholic missionaries in China carried cameras. They outnumbered the diplomats and the journalists, and so their archives in Rome, Paris, Brussels, Boston, and Spokane hold the largest surviving visual record of China before the Cultural Revolution. In those images are baptisms and processions, orphanages and seminaries, sisters at work and bishops at prayer, churches rising in villages and churches in ruins. Most of the images have never been published. Many of the people in them cannot be named. But the Church they show is not a Church that vanished. It is the Church that endured, and that is still there, and the Catholics of China today are its heirs.

To look closely at these photographs, then, is not an exercise in nostalgia. It is a way of seeing what persists: the devotion that outlasted persecution, the faces behind the names in the martyrologies, and the moment when Chinese Catholics themselves took hold of the camera and began to show the world their own Church. My guests have spent years in the archives learning how to see this way, and in this conversation they teach us to see it too.

They are the authors of Time Exposures: Catholic Photography and the Evolution of Modern China. Joseph Ho is a historian of modern China and visual culture at the University of Michigan. Anthony Clark, who joined me last year to talk about Matteo Ricci, is professor of Chinese history and holder of the Edward B. Lindaman Endowed Chair at Whitworth University.

FOLLOW-UP RESOURCES

The book and the authors

Time Exposures: Catholic Photography and the Evolution of Modern China — Joseph W. Ho and Anthony E. Clark (Hong Kong University Press, 2026)

Developing Mission: Photography, Filmmaking, and American Missionaries in Modern China — Joseph W. Ho (Cornell University Press, 2022)

Anthony E. Clark: publications — including China’s Saints and China Gothic

Société des Auxiliaires des Missions (SAM) China Photograph Collection — Whitworth University Library; many of the book’s images, including the 1937 Manila voyage, are digitized here

Previous Church Life Today episodes

The Evangelizing Brilliance and Errors of Matteo Ricci, with Anthony Clark — April 21, 2025

Religion in China, with Ian Johnson — November 1, 2019

From Church Life Journal

In the Footsteps of Dialogue: China and the Legacy of Matteo Ricci — Anthony Clark, February 17, 2026

China’s Divided Church Under Pope Francis — Paul P. Mariani, September 2, 2025

China’s Religious Awakening After Mao — Ian Johnson, June 11, 2020

The Clash Between the Jesuits and Traditional Chinese Square-Earth Cosmology — James Hannam, March 11, 2022

Church Life Today is a partnership between the McGrath Institute for Church Life at the University of Notre Dame and OSV Podcasts from Our Sunday Visitor. Discover more ways to live, learn, and love your Catholic faith at osvpodcasts.com. Sharing stories, starting conversations.